Selecting what to evaluate for school counselors starts with a simple filter: if it doesn’t impact student outcomes or can’t be observed without violating confidentiality, it doesn’t belong in the tool.
Begin with setting a foundation – this tool is meant to do what? Give clear feedback to staff about what they are doing well and where they need improvement. It provides evidence for planning professional development, for giving awards and kudos. It tells you about the health of the Comprehensive school counseling system.
Begin by anchoring to the basics. What is the school counseling program trying to produce—stronger academic planning, clearer career direction, better transitions? Those outcomes drive the evaluation, not generic job duties, not personalities. From there, align to recognized standards to ensure you’re measuring skills that actually build staff and impact student capacity.
Next, narrow to observable practice. Focus on what a manager can see in classrooms, workshops, team meetings, and program artifacts. This keeps the evaluation fair and usable. Private counseling conversations are essential work, but they’re not appropriate for direct evaluation, but you could measure if a school counselor has another school counselor mentor as a support for those confidential pieces.
Then, connect to systems. Strong school counseling isn’t isolated—it shows up in how school counselors use data, collaborate with staff, and expand access for students. Those elements should be visible in the evaluation.
Finally, keep it tight. Limit domains and indicators so the tool drives focus, not compliance. A good evaluation doesn’t try to capture everything—it measures what matters and pushes practice forward.
Create your own, or contact us for a ready to use evaluation tool and rubric.
Download a free copy of our Evaluation Template or Contact Us for more information on using our created tools and materials and training.